How VPNs Affect Speed Tests — We Benchmarked 8 VPN Services

Share:
How VPNs Affect Speed Tests — We Benchmarked 8 VPN Services
🔬 Methodology: 8 VPN services, 30 tests each, nearest server, same wired 1 Gbps desktop. WireGuard, OpenVPN, and proprietary protocols tested separately.

Baseline (No VPN): 941 Mbps ↓ / 937 Mbps ↑ / 4.8ms Ping

Ranked Results

  • Mullvad (WireGuard): 891 Mbps | -5.3% | +4.4ms ✅ Best
  • ExpressVPN (Lightway): 884 Mbps | -6.1% | +3.2ms ✅
  • NordVPN (NordLynx/WG): 861 Mbps | -8.5% | +5.1ms ✅
  • ProtonVPN (WireGuard): 823 Mbps | -12.5% | +7.3ms ✅
  • Surfshark (WireGuard): 739 Mbps | -21.5% | +9.8ms ⚠️
  • CyberGhost (WireGuard): 698 Mbps | -25.8% | +12.1ms ⚠️
  • IPVanish (OpenVPN): 412 Mbps | -56.2% | +18.4ms ❌
  • Generic Free VPN: 87 Mbps | -90.7% | +67ms ❌ Avoid

Key Findings

  • WireGuard beats OpenVPN by 30–50%. Always use WireGuard if available.
  • Free VPNs destroy performance. 90% reduction = HD streaming impossible.
  • No VPN achieves zero speed loss — encryption overhead is physically unavoidable.
  • For speed testing: always disable VPN for baseline. With VPN active, you measure VPN performance, not connection quality.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does my VPN show a higher speed on some tests than others?

Different speed test servers are located in different places. A VPN routes your traffic through its own server before reaching the test server — so you're actually measuring the speed between the VPN server and the test server, not your local connection to the VPN. Test to a server near your VPN exit node for the most accurate VPN performance measurement, or use a speed test that lets you select the server location manually.

How much speed does a VPN typically lose?

Modern WireGuard-based VPNs (NordLynx, Mullvad WireGuard) typically add 5-15% overhead on fast connections — often imperceptible. Older OpenVPN connections can cut speeds by 30-50% due to higher processing overhead. Server distance matters more than protocol: a VPN server 500km away will consistently outperform one 5000km away regardless of protocol. Always connect to the nearest server when speed is the priority.

⚡ Benchmark Your Internet Connection Now

Measure your true download & upload bandwidth, latency jitter, and bufferbloat in real-time with zero ads slowing down your test.

Run Free Speed Test ➔

Frequently Asked Questions

Which VPN service kept the most speed in this benchmark?

Mullvad using WireGuard performed best, retaining 891 Mbps of the 941 Mbps baseline (a 5.3% loss), followed closely by ExpressVPN's Lightway protocol at 884 Mbps.

How much worse are free VPNs compared to paid ones?

The generic free VPN tested dropped speed by 90.7% to just 87 Mbps — severe enough to make HD streaming impossible — compared to single-digit percentage losses on the top paid WireGuard services.

Why might my VPN speed test show a higher number on one server than another?

A VPN test actually measures the path from the VPN server to the test server, not directly to you, so testing against a speed-test server near your VPN's exit node gives the most accurate reading of the VPN's real performance.

Sources & References

See our research methodology for how we combine our own testing with public data sources.

About the Author

Dalto Cardoso is the founder of DCSpeedTest, a digital nomad who has tested internet connections across multiple countries and runs his own VPS infrastructure for clients worldwide. He holds certifications from Google and Meta Blueprint.